Peer Review Process

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan is a peer-reviewed, open-access scientific journal published by Poltekkes Kemenkes Palu, Indonesia. The journal implements a rigorous, fair, transparent, independent, and confidential peer-review process to ensure the scientific quality, originality, relevance, validity, and academic integrity of manuscripts submitted for publication.

The journal considers peer review an essential component of scholarly publishing, particularly in health sciences, where the reliability of research findings, methodological rigor, and compliance with ethical standards are fundamental to advancing scientific knowledge, evidence-based healthcare practices, and public health.

All submitted manuscripts are evaluated according to the journal's focus and scope, Author Guidelines, publication ethics policies, and established standards of scientific reporting. The journal covers nursing, health law, nutrition, midwifery, environmental health, public health, reproductive health, health education, health promotion, and related health sciences.

Editorial decisions are based on scientific merit, methodological rigor, originality, relevance, clarity, and compliance with research and publication ethics.

Submission to Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan does not guarantee manuscript acceptance or publication.

1. Initial Editorial Screening

All manuscripts submitted to Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan undergo an initial screening by the Editorial Team to determine whether they meet the journal's submission requirements and are suitable for further scientific evaluation.

The initial screening includes an assessment of:

  1. Scope and Relevance: Whether the manuscript falls within the journal's focus and scope and provides a meaningful contribution to health sciences, healthcare practice, health education, or public health.

  2. Compliance with Author Guidelines: Whether the manuscript follows the journal's required formatting, structure, referencing style, manuscript template, and submission procedures.

  3. Scientific Quality: Whether the research questions, objectives, study design, methodology, and presentation demonstrate an adequate level of scientific rigor.

  4. Originality and Contribution: Whether the manuscript presents original findings, perspectives, or scholarly contributions and avoids inappropriate duplication of previously published research.

  5. Research Ethics: Whether the manuscript includes relevant information concerning research ethics approval, informed consent, participant protection, patient confidentiality, and other ethical requirements, where applicable.

  6. Completeness of Submission: Whether all required documents, author information, declarations, tables, figures, supplementary materials, and other submission requirements have been provided.

  7. Language and Presentation: Whether the manuscript is written clearly, logically organized, and sufficiently developed to permit meaningful scientific assessment.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements may be returned to the authors for technical correction or rejected without external peer review.

The Editorial Team may also reject a manuscript at this stage if it falls outside the journal's focus and scope, contains fundamental methodological weaknesses, lacks sufficient scientific contribution, or raises substantial concerns regarding originality or publication ethics.

Only manuscripts that meet the journal's initial editorial requirements will proceed to the next stage of evaluation.

2. Similarity and Ethical Screening

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan screens submitted manuscripts for textual similarity, potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, and other possible violations of research and publication ethics.

The journal uses Turnitin as a similarity-detection tool to support the assessment of manuscript originality.

In accordance with the journal's Plagiarism Policy, the maximum permitted similarity index is 20%.

Manuscripts with a similarity index exceeding 20% may be returned to the authors for correction and reassessment or rejected, depending on the nature, extent, and seriousness of the identified similarities.

A similarity index of 20% or below does not automatically guarantee acceptance or establish that the manuscript is free from plagiarism.

Similarity scores are treated as preliminary indicators rather than definitive evidence of plagiarism. The Editorial Team evaluates the nature, source, context, concentration, and extent of matching text, including whether material has been properly cited or legitimately reused.

Ethical screening may also include an assessment of:

  1. Potential plagiarism, self-plagiarism, or inappropriate text recycling.

  2. Duplicate or redundant submission and publication.

  3. Inappropriate reuse, fabrication, falsification, or manipulation of research data, figures, images, and other scientific materials.

  4. Authorship disputes, inaccurate author contributions, or misleading authorship declarations.

  5. Missing, inadequate, or inconsistent research ethics approval and informed consent information, where applicable.

  6. Undisclosed funding sources or conflicts of interest.

  7. Inappropriate or undisclosed use of artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies.

  8. Other potential violations of research integrity or publication ethics.

If concerns are identified, the Editorial Team may request clarification, additional documentation, or manuscript revisions.

Depending on the seriousness of the issue and the available evidence, the manuscript may be returned for correction, subjected to further ethical assessment, or rejected in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

3. Peer Review Model

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan implements a single-blind peer-review process.

Under this model, the identities of reviewers are concealed from the authors, while reviewers have access to the identities of the authors.

The single-blind review model is intended to support independent scientific evaluation while maintaining reviewer confidentiality and protecting the integrity of the editorial decision-making process.

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial editorial and ethical screening are assigned to qualified reviewers with relevant expertise in the manuscript's subject area, research methodology, or analytical approaches.

Each manuscript undergoing peer review is evaluated by at least two reviewers to ensure an adequate and independent assessment of its scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, and relevance.

The handling editor may invite additional reviewers when the existing evaluations are insufficient, contradictory, or require specialized scientific or methodological expertise.

Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, subject expertise, research experience, professional competence, and ability to provide independent and impartial assessments.

Individuals with relevant conflicts of interest must disclose those conflicts and should not participate in a review when their impartiality may reasonably be compromised.

Reviewer identities and confidential review communications are protected in accordance with the journal's editorial policies.

4. Reviewer Responsibilities and Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, constructive, and evidence-based scientific assessments.

Their primary responsibility is to assist the editor in making informed publication decisions and to help authors improve the scientific quality, clarity, and integrity of their manuscripts.

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts according to the following criteria:

  1. Originality and Novelty: The extent to which the manuscript presents new scientific findings, perspectives, or insights that contribute to health sciences and related disciplines.

  2. Relevance and Scientific Significance: The importance of the research objectives and their contribution to scientific knowledge, healthcare services, nursing, midwifery, nutrition, health education, or public health practice.

  3. Research Design and Methodology: The appropriateness and rigor of the research design, sampling procedures, research instruments, data collection methods, interventions, and methodological reporting.

  4. Data Quality and Analysis: The adequacy and reliability of data collection, statistical or qualitative analyses, and the interpretation of research findings.

  5. Validity of Findings and Conclusions: Whether the conclusions are supported by the presented evidence and appropriately acknowledge methodological limitations.

  6. Literature Review and Theoretical Framework: The adequacy, relevance, credibility, and currency of cited literature and the application of appropriate theoretical or conceptual foundations.

  7. Research Ethics: Compliance with applicable ethical standards, including research ethics approval, informed consent, privacy protection, confidentiality, and participant or animal welfare, where relevant.

  8. Presentation and Organization: The clarity, logical structure, readability, scientific writing quality, tables, figures, references, and overall presentation of the manuscript.

  9. Transparency and Reproducibility: The adequacy of reporting, clarity of research procedures, and availability of relevant data or supporting materials when appropriate.

  10. Publication Ethics: Potential concerns relating to plagiarism, duplicate publication, conflicts of interest, inappropriate authorship, data manipulation, research integrity, or other ethical violations.

Reviewers should provide clear, specific, and scientifically justified comments that distinguish major scientific concerns from minor editorial suggestions.

Criticism must focus on the manuscript and its scientific content rather than the personal characteristics or institutional affiliations of the authors.

Reviewers must not request unnecessary citations for the purpose of increasing their own citation counts, those of their colleagues, or the journal's citation metrics.

Reviewer recommendations must be based on independent scientific judgment and must not be generated through unauthorized AI-assisted evaluation of confidential manuscripts.

5. Editorial Decision

The handling editor evaluates the reviewers' reports together with the manuscript's scientific quality, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and compliance with the editorial and ethical requirements of Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan.

The possible editorial decisions are:

  1. Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revision, subject to any remaining editorial or production requirements.

  2. Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited changes, such as clarification, correction, additional explanation, improvement of scientific presentation, or minor adjustments before a final decision can be made.

  3. Major Revision: The manuscript requires substantial improvements to methodology reporting, data analysis, interpretation, discussion, scientific arguments, or other important components before it can be reconsidered.

  4. Reject: The manuscript is not suitable for publication because of insufficient scientific contribution, fundamental methodological weaknesses, lack of relevance, unresolved ethical concerns, or other significant deficiencies.

A decision requiring minor or major revision does not guarantee acceptance.

Revised manuscripts will be reassessed to determine whether the authors have adequately addressed the scientific and editorial concerns.

The final editorial decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or the editor formally authorized to make the relevant decision.

Reviewers provide scientific recommendations but do not independently determine whether a manuscript will be accepted or rejected.

The editor may request additional reviews or make a decision that differs from a reviewer's recommendation when justified by the scientific evidence and the journal's editorial policies.

6. Revision Process

When revision is requested, authors must revise their manuscripts according to the editorial decision and reviewer comments.

Authors should submit the revised manuscript within the deadline specified in the editorial decision letter.

A revised submission should normally include:

  1. A revised manuscript incorporating the requested corrections and improvements.

  2. A point-by-point response addressing each comment from the editor and reviewers.

  3. A clear explanation for any recommendation that the authors have not adopted, supported by an appropriate scientific justification.

  4. Additional data, references, ethical documentation, or supporting information requested by the Editorial Team.

  5. Clearly identified manuscript changes when required by the Editorial Office.

Authors are expected to respond professionally, accurately, and comprehensively to all substantive reviewer and editorial comments.

If additional time is required, the corresponding author should contact the Editorial Office before the revision deadline and provide a reasonable explanation.

Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or assigned to additional reviewers when further independent scientific assessment is necessary.

The handling editor will assess whether the authors have adequately addressed the major concerns before making a subsequent editorial decision.

Failure to submit a revised manuscript within the specified period without an approved extension may result in the manuscript being administratively closed or treated as withdrawn from consideration, subject to the journal's established procedures.

Authors who wish to resubmit a previously rejected manuscript must follow the Editorial Office's instructions. Resubmission does not guarantee reconsideration or acceptance.

7. Review Timeline

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan aims to process submitted manuscripts efficiently while maintaining the scientific rigor, independence, confidentiality, and integrity of editorial assessment.

The duration of the peer-review process may vary depending on:

  1. The scientific complexity and subject area of the manuscript.

  2. The availability of qualified reviewers.

  3. The need for additional methodological or specialist assessments.

  4. The extent of revisions required.

  5. The time taken by authors to respond to editorial and reviewer comments.

  6. The need for additional ethical verification or supporting documentation.

  7. Editorial and publication management considerations.

Authors will be informed of significant editorial decisions through the journal's Online Journal Systems (OJS) platform or other official communication channels.

The Editorial Office may contact authors when additional information, clarification, revision, or other action is required.

Any review timelines published by the journal should be understood as indicative targets rather than guaranteed deadlines.

Delays may occur when suitable reviewers are difficult to identify, additional expertise is required, or further scientific or ethical assessment becomes necessary.

The journal remains committed to managing manuscripts responsibly while prioritizing scientific quality and fair editorial evaluation over unnecessarily accelerated publication decisions.

8. Reviewer Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest

Manuscripts submitted for peer review are confidential scholarly documents.

Reviewers must not share, distribute, disclose, reproduce, or use unpublished manuscript information for personal, professional, financial, or research advantage without appropriate authorization.

Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting a review invitation.

Such conflicts may include financial interests, academic competition, professional collaboration, institutional relationships, personal relationships, or other circumstances that could compromise independent judgment.

A reviewer who identifies a conflict of interest that may affect their objectivity should decline the invitation or promptly notify the handling editor.

Editors must also disclose relevant conflicts of interest and arrange for an independent editor to manage a manuscript when necessary.

Under the journal's single-blind peer-review model, reviewers know the identities of the authors, while reviewer identities remain confidential and are not disclosed to the authors through the ordinary review process.

Reviewer reports and editorial correspondence will be handled confidentially in accordance with the journal's editorial procedures.

Reviewers must not upload unpublished manuscripts, confidential research data, or reviewer correspondence into unauthorized AI systems or third-party platforms that cannot adequately protect manuscript confidentiality.

These requirements are consistent with the journal's Conflict of Interest Policy and Artificial Intelligence (AI) Usage Policy.

9. Editorial Independence and Fairness

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan is committed to editorial independence, impartial scientific assessment, and fair treatment of all authors.

Editorial decisions are based on scientific merit, methodological quality, originality, relevance, research integrity, and compliance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

The journal does not discriminate against authors on the basis of nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, institutional affiliation, disability, or other characteristics unrelated to the scientific quality and ethical acceptability of their work.

Editors must not allow personal relationships, institutional interests, commercial considerations, funding sources, academic positions, or external pressure to improperly influence editorial decisions.

All manuscripts will be evaluated according to consistent scientific and ethical standards appropriate to their research design, article type, and subject area.

Manuscripts submitted by researchers affiliated with Poltekkes Kemenkes Palu, the journal's publishing institution, are subject to the same editorial screening, peer-review procedures, and scientific evaluation as submissions from other institutions.

Institutional affiliation with the journal's publisher does not guarantee favorable treatment, manuscript acceptance, or publication.

Where an editor has a relevant conflict of interest, the manuscript must be reassigned to another qualified editor to ensure an independent and objective evaluation.

The Editorial Board is responsible for maintaining fairness, transparency, confidentiality, and accountability throughout the peer-review and decision-making processes.

10. Research Ethics and Publication Integrity

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan expects all authors to comply with applicable research ethics standards and to report their research accurately, transparently, and responsibly.

For studies involving human participants, identifiable patient information, human biological materials, or animals, authors must provide relevant information concerning research ethics approval, informed consent, confidentiality, and participant protection, where applicable.

Where ethical approval is required, authors must provide appropriate information concerning approval from a recognized research ethics committee or institutional review board.

When ethical approval is not required or an exemption has been granted, the authors may be required to provide an appropriate explanation or supporting documentation.

The journal may request additional information when the ethical basis of a study requires clarification.

Manuscripts involving suspected research misconduct, fabricated or falsified data, plagiarism, duplicate submission, inappropriate authorship practices, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other serious ethical concerns may be suspended from editorial processing while the matter is assessed.

Any allegations of research misconduct will be handled in accordance with the journal's established Allegations of Research Misconduct Policy.

Where misconduct or serious ethical violations are substantiated, the journal may reject the manuscript or take other appropriate editorial action.

If concerns arise after publication, the journal may consider a correction, Expression of Concern, or retraction depending on the circumstances, the available evidence, and the applicable publication ethics procedures.

All authors, editors, and reviewers are expected to comply with the journal's policies concerning Publication Ethics, Authorship Criteria, Plagiarism, Conflicts of Interest, and the responsible use of Artificial Intelligence.

11. Appeals and Complaints

Authors who believe that an editorial decision resulted from a significant factual error, misunderstanding of the manuscript, procedural irregularity, or relevant conflict of interest may submit a formal appeal to the Editorial Office of Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan.

An appeal should clearly identify the editorial decision being challenged, explain the grounds for reconsideration, and provide relevant supporting evidence.

Disagreement with an unfavorable editorial decision alone does not constitute sufficient grounds for an appeal.

Where reasonably possible, the appeal will be assessed by an editor who was not directly responsible for the original decision or by another independent editorial representative.

The journal may uphold the original decision, request additional scientific assessment, or reconsider the decision when the available evidence justifies doing so.

The outcome of the appeal will be communicated through the journal's official communication channels.

Complaints concerning reviewer conduct, editorial handling, conflicts of interest, or peer-review procedures will be assessed fairly, confidentially, and objectively in accordance with the journal's applicable policies and publication ethics principles.

Appeals and complaints must be submitted professionally and supported by relevant information.

The Editorial Board reserves the right to determine the appropriate review and reconsideration procedures while maintaining fairness, transparency, and editorial independence.

12. Post-Review and Production

Once a manuscript has been formally accepted for publication, it proceeds to the journal's publication preparation process.

This process may include:

  1. Copyediting and language editing.

  2. Verification of references and citations.

  3. Manuscript formatting and layout preparation.

  4. Proofreading and technical quality checks.

  5. Verification of author information, institutional affiliations, and article metadata.

  6. Confirmation of relevant ethical declarations, funding information, and conflicts of interest.

  7. Preparation of Digital Object Identifier (DOI) information and other bibliographic metadata, as applicable.

  8. Final editorial and production approval before publication.

Authors may be requested to review the final proofs and correct production-related errors within the period specified by the Editorial Office.

Proof corrections should generally be limited to typographical errors, formatting issues, and inaccuracies introduced during manuscript production.

Substantive changes to an accepted manuscript require prior editorial approval.

Acceptance does not authorize authors to make major unapproved changes or submit the same manuscript for publication elsewhere.

Accepted articles will be published according to the journal's established publication schedule and applicable editorial policies once all required editorial and production procedures have been completed.

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan publishes four regular issues annually, scheduled for February, May, August, and November.

Assignment of accepted manuscripts to particular issues is determined by the Editorial Board based on editorial readiness, publication capacity, and the journal's publication arrangements.

13. Policy Implementation

Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan is committed to maintaining a peer-review process that is rigorous, confidential, impartial, constructive, transparent, and consistent with recognized standards of scholarly publishing.

The journal implements a single-blind peer-review system involving at least two reviewers to support independent scientific evaluation and maintain the quality of published research.

All editorial decisions must be based on the scientific merit, originality, methodological rigor, relevance, and ethical acceptability of submitted manuscripts.

The journal is committed to maintaining consistency between its peer-review procedures and other applicable policies, including:

  1. Publication Ethics.

  2. Author Guidelines.

  3. Manuscript Types.

  4. Authorship Criteria.

  5. Plagiarism Policy.

  6. Conflict of Interest Policy.

  7. Artificial Intelligence (AI) Usage Policy.

  8. Allegations of Research Misconduct.

  9. Post-Publication Discussion.

  10. Publication Schedule.

The Editorial Board reserves the right to periodically review and update this policy to reflect developments in peer-review practices, research integrity, publication ethics, and editorial management.

By submitting a manuscript to Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan, authors acknowledge that their work is subject to the journal's editorial screening, similarity assessment, peer-review procedures, revision requirements, and publication ethics policies.

Compliance with these procedures is essential to maintaining the scientific quality, credibility, transparency, and integrity of published research.

Through this policy, Poltekita: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan reaffirms its commitment to independent scientific evaluation, responsible scholarly publishing, and the dissemination of reliable, original, and high-quality research in health sciences.